| Men's Golf | David Ake
| Sr.
| Topsfield, Mass. / Masconomet |
| Women's Soccer | Jillian Arnault
| Sr.
| Clay, N.Y. / Cicero-North Syracuse |
| Women's Track and Field | Alexandra Atkinson
| So.
| Weston, Conn. / Weston |
| Men's Crew | Marc Cassone
| Sr.
| Plattsburgh, N.Y. / Plattsburgh |
| Men's Crew | James Clinton
| Jr.
| Vancouver, B.C. / St. George's |
| Men's Lacrosse | Frank Coughlin
| Jr.
| Manhasset, N.Y. / Manhasset |
| Men's Ice Hockey | Ethan Cox
| Sr.
| Richmond, B.C. / |
| Women's Crew | Laura Crawford
| Sr.
| Allentown, N.J. / The Hun School |
| Football | Brian Crockett
| Fr.
| Passaic, N.J. / St. Mary's |
| Women's Swimming and Diving | Jenna Daly
| So.
| Garden City, N.Y. / Garden City |
| Women's Tennis | Elise DeRose
| Sr.
| Williamsville, N.Y. / Nichols School |
| Women's Cross Country | Emma Eckerstrom
| So.
| Boyas, Md. / Northwest |
| Men's Track and Field | Jeremy Fisher
| Sr.
| Fredericksburg, Va. / James Monroe |
| Women's Basketball | Katie Garman
| Sr.
| Poplar Grove, Ill. / North Boone |
| Men's Cross Country | Dan Gleason
| Jr.
| Norwalk, Conn. / King and Low-Heywood Thomas School |
| Men's Lacrosse | Tim Harrington
| Sr.
| Lutherville, Md. / Loyola Blakefield |
| Men's Swimming and Diving | Devon Healy
| Jr.
| New Canaan, Conn. / New Canaan |
| Softball | Michelle Hollebeke
| So.
| North Reading, MA. / Phillips Academy |
| Women's Cross Country | Hilary Hooley
| Jr.
| Fayetteville, N.Y. / Fayetteville-Manlius |
| Women's Crew | Vicky Hulit
| Sr.
| Rye, N.Y. / Rye |
| Women's Tennis | Samantha Inacker
| Sr.
| Lake Forest, Ill. / Lake Forest |
| Women's Swimming and Diving | Emily Kelly
| Jr.
| Potomac, Md. / Holton-Arms School |
| Men's Track and Field | Jonathan Knowlton
| Jr.
| North Salem, N.Y. / North Salem |
| Men's Soccer | Chris Koontz
| Sr.
| Miller Place, N.Y. / St. Anthony's |
| Women's Field Hockey | Kirsten Lalli
| Jr.
| Pound Ridge, N.Y. / Fox Lane |
| Women's Lacrosse | Meghan Lawler
| Sr.
| Liverpool, N.Y. / Liverpool |
| Women's Volleyball | Kelsea Loveless
| Sr.
| Lubbock, Texas / Lubbock Trinity Christian |
| Men's Basketball | Brett Marfurt
| So.
| Guilderland, N.Y. / Guilderland |
| Men's Ice Hockey | Kevin McNamara
| So.
| Chesnut Hill, Mass. / Belmont Hill |
| Women's Ice Hockey | Hannah Milan
| Jr.
| Great Barrington, Mass. / N.A. Hockey Academy |
| Women's Track and Field | Michele Miller
| Jr.
| Silver Spring, Md. / John F. Kennedy |
| Cheerleading | Liz Paulino
| Rf.
| |
| Women's Volleyball | Casey Ritt
| Jr.
| Colorado Springs, Colo. / St. Mary's |
| Men's Soccer | Chris Salmon
| Sr.
| Auburn, Wash. / Lakeside School |
| Women's Soccer | Ellie Schmidt
| So.
| Portland, Ore. / St. Mary's Academy |
| Women's Softball | Nicole Siedhof
| Jr.
| Canton, Pa. / Canton |
| Football | Pat Simonds
| Sr.
| Sidney, N.Y. / Sidney |
| Men's Tennis | Sean Spellberg
| So.
| Naples, Fla. / Community School of Naples |
| Women's Softball | Kimberley Spinks
| Sr.
| Bristow, Va. / Stonewall Jackson |
| Women's Lacrosse | Katie Sullivan
| So.
| Cockeysville, Md. / Bryn Mawr Academy |
| Men's Golf | Neil Thompson
| Jr.
| Sherborn, Mass / Dover Sherborn |
| Men's Cross Country | Lyle Tolli
| Sr.
| Lockport, N.Y. / Lockport |
| Men's Basketball | Mike Venezia
| Jr.
| Westfield, N.J. / Westfield |
| Football | Carlton Walker
| Sr.
| Columbis, Ohio / Columbus |
| Women's Ice Hockey | Jessi Waters
| Jr.
| Menlo Park, Calif. / Westminster |
| Women's Field Hockey | Alli Waugh
| Jr.
| Briarcliff Manor, N.Y. / Briarcliff |
| Women's Crew | Brittany Wolf
| Rf.
| |